App Proposal Evaluation Rubric

The following are suggested criteria to consider when evaluating the presentations. Since most of the criteria are subjective, it is reasonable for you to apply your own rules (please do share yours if you care). You are only responsible for entering a number for each category.

 

5

4

3

2

1

Use of Visual Aid

High quality with clear app layout  sketch

Good quality with app layout sketch

Quality is ok, can see some sketch of app layout

Some visual aid, difficult to make out what the app will look like

Bad visual aid in general

Explain how technical requirements are met

Include a slide (or two) that explains how the app meets all the technical requirements

Include a slide (or two) that explains how the app meets some of the technical requirements

Describe how the app meets the technical requirements with no visual aid

Mention the technical requirements without describing how they are met

Made no mention to the specified technical requirements

Confidence in meeting deadline

Very sure that the team can complete their app as proposed

Somewhat sure that the team can complete their app as proposed

The team may be able to complete their app as proposed.

The demo does not provide confidence that the team can meet the deadline.

It is very clear that the team will not be able to meet the demanding deadline.

Interesting App

I will wait in line to use the app

I wish the app is here and I can try it out

If the app is done, I want to try it.

I will try it to be polite.

I will be rude and won't even try it.

 

Three person team: without mention texture map and transformed textures will receive 0 from Kelvin