Progress Demo Evaluation Rubric

The following are suggested criteria to consider when evaluating the presentations. Since most of the criteria are subjective, it is reasonable for you to apply your own rules (please do share yours if you care). You are only responsible for entering a number for each category.

·         Interesting:

 

5

4

3

2

1

Did you enjoy watching the demo?

The app was interesting and I really want to spend more time finding out more.

The app was sort of interesting, I enjoyed watching the demo.

I did not mind watching the demo.

If I didn't watch the app demo, it would have been ok.

I hated every second of watching the demo.

 

 

·         Innovative App:

 

5

4

3

2

1

Originality of idea and coolness

First time seeing app like this.

Interesting difference from app I know of.

Small difference from apps I know of.

About the same as apps I know of.

Identical to many apps I know of.

 

 

·         Technically Challenging:

 

5

4

3

2

1

Complexity

The app is complex with interesting objects.

App is moderately complex with interesting objects.

App is not complex.

App is straightforward with simple objects.

App is trivial.

Difficulty

Editing and view manipulations are intelligent and interesting.

Editing and view manipulations are somewhat intelligent and somewhat interesting.

Editing and view manipulations are straightforward and not quite interesting.

Editing and view manipulations are straightforward and not interesting.

Editing and view manipulations are very simple and dull.

 

 

·         Confidence in meeting deadline:

 

5

4

3

2

1

Based on the demo

Very sure that the team can complete their app as proposed

Somewhat sure that the team can complete their app as proposed

The team may be able to complete their app as proposed.

The state of the app does not provide confidence that the team can meet the deadline.

It is very clear that the team will not be able to meet the demanding deadline.

 

I believe the team is in trouble.

 

Three person team: without mention Texture and Texture transforms will receive 0 from Kelvin