Energy & Environment I NAME

HW#7

Due Friday, November 16, 2001

1. In HW#4 you estimated the amount of gasoline (ie, gallons per year) you use for automotive transportation. Now your task is to estimate the amount of pollution you cause through our dependency on the automobile.

Assume a chemical formula of C8H15 for gasoline. Based on this formula, prove that complete combustion of 1 kg (kilogram) of gasoline results in the emission of 3.17 kg of CO2.

Show your calculation here:

Complete combustion of one kmol of C8H15 produces 8 kmol of CO2. The mass of the fuel = 12x8+15 = 111 kg. The mass of the CO2 is 8 x (12+2x16) = 352 kg.

Thus, 1 kg of fuel produces 352/111 = 3.17 kg of CO2

 

Assume one US gallon of gasoline has a mass of 2.85 kg. Assume the vehicle travels (on average) 25 miles per gallon. Based on this information, prove that the CO2 emission is 360 grams per mile.

Show your calculation here:

1 gallon fuel is equivalent to 2.85 kg fuel is equivalent to 25 miles traveled is equivalent to 2.85x3.17 kg = 9.04 kg CO2 emitted. Thus, the CO2 emission may be expressed as:

9040 grams/ 25 miles = 360 grams/mile

 

The CO emission limit for automobiles sold in the USA (set by the USEPA) is about 1% of the CO2 emission determined above (it is 3.4 grams per mile). Based on your personal dependency on the automobile, how much CO2 (as kg per year) and how much CO (as kg per year) do you emit?

Show your calculation here:

CO2: (360 grams/mile) x (25 mpg/your average mpg) x (miles per year traveled/average number of people in car) x (1 kg/ 1000 grams)

CO: (3.4 grams/mile) x (miles per year traveled/average number of people in car) x (1 kg/ 1000 grams)

 

Find the US emission limits for UHC and NOx from automobiles. Determine your emissions of UHC (as kg per year) and NOx (as kg per year) from your dependency on the automobile.

Show your calculation here:

Table 8.6 on p. 270 of your textbook gives the US limits for UHC and NOx. Thus:

UHC: (0.25 grams/mile) x (miles per year traveled/average number of people in car) x (1 kg/ 1000 grams)

NOx: (0.4 grams/mile) x (miles per year traveled/average number of people in car) x (1 kg/ 1000 grams)

 

2. Now let’s consider pollution from the combined cycle combustion turbine, which is becoming important for electricity generation in the Pacific Northwest. The fuel is natural gas. Large state-of-the-art combined cycle power plants have a rated electrical power output of 250 MW and an overall (fuel to electricity) efficiency of 58%. Assume the combined cycle power plant runs at rated power 8000 hours per year (that is, its capacity factor is 8000/8760 = 0.91).

We need to know the heating value of the natural gas. On p. 3:7, Bodansky gives this as 1033 BTU per scf. A standard cubic foot of natural gas has a mass of about 0.022 kg. Converting BTU to kJ and scf to kg, gives a heating value of about 49,500 kJ/kg. We’ll assume 50 MJ/kg. Unfortunately, this is the Higher Heating Value (HHV), which assumes the H2O in the exhaust gases is condensed. However, most combustion equipment does not condense the exhaust H2O – it goes up the stack (or out the tail pipe) as gas. The heat of condensation is not captured! Engines, including combined cycle power plants are rated on the basis of the fuel’s Lower Heating Value (LHV). This assumes the H2O remains as a gas. For natural gas, LHV @ 0.9 x HHV. Thus, for this problem, the heating value we use is LHV = 45 MJ/kg.

Determine the kg of natural gas burned per year by the combined cycle power plant.

Show your calculation here:

Efficiency = W/QH = W/(mFLHV) = Power/(mass per second of fuel x LHV).

Thus: mass per second of fuel = Power/(Efficiency x LHV)

Mass per second of fuel = (250 MJ/s)/(0.58 x 45 MJ/kg) = 9.58 kg/s

Mass per year of fuel = (9.58 kg/s) x (3600 s/hr) x (8000 hr/yr) = 276 million kg/yr

 

The combustion chambers of the combined cycle (in the gas turbine engine) burn the natural gas with a large excess of air. This reduces the flame temperature, greatly curtailing the formation of NOx. Early on we learned high efficiency requires the heat to be added at high temperature. This is still true! However, the TH is the temperature of the burnt gases entering the turbine of the gas turbine engine. And this temperature is limited by the turbine blade material properties and the turbine blade cooling methods used. Current technology limits TH to a maximum of about 1700K (2600 deg F), and many engines run no hotter than about 1500K (2240 deg F) at the turbine inlet. The flame on the other hand, will produce minimal NOx if it is maintained not much hotter than 1800K. This requires an air-fuel ratio for the flame of about double that for chemically correct burning. The excess air is the diluent. The combustor is lean and premixed.

The chemical equation below is for a combined cycle running with 225% excess air (some of the excess air is added after the flame, so the flame doesn’t get so lean it blows out). The natural composition is CH3.8.

CH3.8 + (1.95)(1+225/100)O2 + 3.773(1.95)(1+225/100)N2 ®

CO2 + 1.90H2O + (1.95)(225/100)O2 + 3.773(1.95)(1+225/100)N2

Calculate the kg of CO2 emitted per year.

Show your calculation here:

1 kmol of CH3.8 of fuel produces 1 kmol of CO2. The respective masses are CH3.8 = 12+3.8 = 15.8 kg and CO2 = 12+2x16 = 44 kg.

Thus, 1 kg of natural gas produces 44/15.8 = 2.785 kg of CO2.

The annual emission of CO2 is 276 million x 2.785 = 769 million kg/yr.

 

Measurements of exhaust emissions are done on dry, molar basis. Thus, by the chemical equation, the exhaust measurements of CO2 and O2 would be:

3.4% CO2 and 15% O2. Verify these values.

Show your calculation here:

From the chemical equation above:

Moles of dry products = 1 + 1.95x225/100 + 3.773x1.95x(1+225/100) = 29.30 kmol

CO2: 1 x 100/ 29.30 = 3.4%

O2: (1.95x225/100) x 100/ 29.30 = 15.0%

 

The CO and NOx exhaust measurements for this combined cycle power plant are: CO = 0.001% and NOx = 0.001%. Find the annual emissions of CO and NOx (as kg per year for each pollutant). NOx is assumed to have the mass of NO2.

Show your calculation here:

CO: (0.001/3.4) x (28/44) x 769 million kg/yr = 0.144 million kg/yr

NOx: (0.001/3.4) x (46/44) x 769 million kg/yr = 0.237 million kg/yr

 

 

Additional comment: It is useful to compare emissions on the basis of the fuel burned and the work done. This comparison is made in the table below, assuming 1 kg of fuel.

 

Gasoline Engine

Combined Cycle (Nat Gas)

Mass of fuel burned (kg)

1

1

LHV (MJ/kg)

44

45

Chemical Energy (MJ)

44

45

Efficiency (%)

18 (fuel to wheel)

58 (fuel to electricity)

Work (MJ)

0.18x44 = 7.92

0.58x45 = 26.10

CO2 as grams/kg-fuel

3170

2785

CO2 (kg)

3.17

2.875

CO2 as grams/MJ

3170/7.92 = 400

2785/26.10 = 107

CO2:CO:NOx (grams/mile)

360: 3.4: 0.4

 

CO2:CO:NOx

(million kg/yr)

 

769: 0.144: 0.237

CO as grams/kg-fuel

3170x3.4/360 = 29.9

2785x0.144/769 = 0.52

CO as grams/MJ

400x3.4/360 = 3.8

107x0.144/769 = 0.02

NOx as grams/kg-fuel

3170x0.4/360 = 3.5

2785x0.237/769 = 0.86

NOx as grams/MJ

400x0.4/360 = 0.44

107x0.237/769 = 0.033

Note 1: The combined cycle assumed in this HW has state-of-the-art low-NOx (and low-CO) combustors. Systems of a few years ago had CO and NOx emissions of about 0.0025% each. Several of these systems installed exhaust emission control catalysts to reduce the CO and NOx to under 0.001% each. (This caused an ammonia emission of about 0.001%. Ammonia is used since it chemically reduces NOx: NH3 + NOx ® N2 + …)

Note 2: Most combined cycle power plants are on interruptable natural gas service. The price is lower, but the supplier can cut off the supply, especially in the winter when the gas is badly needed for residential and commercial heating. Thus, most combined cycle systems are equipped to run on oil (#2 diesel oil) if necessary. This increases emissions! A month of running on oil can significantly impact the annual CO, NOx, SO2, and particulate emissions of the power plant. During running on oil, the combustors may need to be injected with water to control the NOx (by cooling the flame). This adds capital and operating costs.