I have written a few contemplated reflections before, but this class’s focus on fossil fuel contemplation has really caught my attention.
There are many talks right now about substituting fossil fuel with electricity as vehicles’ main source of energy. The rise of electric cars, especially the Tesla models, is an example. Although electric energy is usually viewed as a clean source of energy, the benefits of this energy is not the same everywhere. In fact, it could prove to be more destructive than fossil fuel in developing countries. People in developing countries tend to destroy their ecosystem by producing electricity. Since many of these countries could not access clean and eco-friendly ways to produce electricity, they tend to produce energy via hydropower dams. These dams could destroy the livelihood of many people who depends on the water resources from the rivers.
I was born in the Southern part of Vietnam, where rivers are central to life. The Mekong-the grandest river of all, stems from China and flows through Myanmar, Laos, Thailand, Cambodia and Vietnam.
Mekong River Watershed, source Wikipedia
The Mekong river is more than just a river, it is a source of life. It provides people fishes to eat, freshwater to drink, fertile silt and sedimentation to cultivate and many other essential functions for agricultural production. However, China hadalredy built six hydropower dams along the river, and at least 14 more dams will be complete in 10 more years. One of these dams, the Lancang dam, in the Upper Mekong region has adversely impacted the Lower Mekong regions.
Lancang River Dams in China, source: International River
According to International River, the Lancang dam is threatening Southeast Asia’s food security by blocking fish immigration, reducing natural sedimentation deposit, and creating erosions. People who live in the Lower Mekong delta are facing great threat from these dams, particularly the indigenous communities along the river. Importantly, competition for scarce water sources create tension on international scale.
First Blog Response
Dear, Sammy Huynh
As a National Geographic article put it “the people of Southeast Asia need the clean electricity—but also the fish and rice that an undammed river provides” (https://www.nationalgeographic.com/magazine/2015/05/mekong-river-dams/) . Dams and water right issues generally involved careful examination of a complex set of tradeoffs/ a complex cost-benefit analysis. As @Sammyhuynh so accurately pointed out these damns not only have huge negative environmental effects, but also huge negative social effects.
Beyond the negative externalities there are also complex issues of inter country politics, properties rights and indigenous rights. Interestingly enough in the 60s the US actually advocated for the construction these hydropower dams on the lower Mekong, hoping to develop the region’s economy and reduce the spread of communism in the region. These plans were slowed and in the 90s China (not Southeast Asia), was first to dam the main river. It is so interesting how complex global politics are intertwined with such issues and how indirect national policy discussions from decades past can have lasting impact.
On a different note- “A 2013 analysis by the International Energy Agency predicts that the region’s demand for power will increase by 80 percent in the next 20 years” (nat geo article above). So, there is a huge need for energy in this part of the world. This is where the trade off part of hydropower comes in. As we learned in class fossil fuel derived forms of energy cause climate change, so clean power sources are favorable- like hydropower from Mekong. (especially for small, poor countries such as Laos). In Loas official build the Thai-financed Xayaburi damn along remote parts of the Mekong hoping to be the “battery of the Southeast Asia” and to attract foreign investment. They however did not get approval for the damn and denied building it for years.
One overarching theme about these dams seems to be that the burden and negative externalities of the dam seem to fall on the poorest and most vulnerable while the government reps the benefits either directly or through rents. This seems to be a reoccurring theme in our class.
I really liked how you brought up some of the negative aspects of hydropower. Many people naturally assume because it is a renewable source of energy it is all good, but the water rights and dam issues are so complex and emotionally loaded it is often feels reductionist to make a simple cost-benefit analysis. There are so many environmental, social, political, economical implications involved in damning a river. It is never straight forward- thanks for the article
Pingback: tadalafil and voice problems
Pingback: write my essay please
Pingback: custom essay writing help
Pingback: buy essay cheap online
Pingback: custom essay meister review
Pingback: professional college application essay writers
Pingback: essay writing company reviews
Pingback: reviews of essay writing services
Pingback: write my law essay
Pingback: buy essays online for college
Pingback: united pharmacy online
Pingback: iras pharmacy oxycodone
Pingback: pharmacy warfarin dosing
Pingback: tadalafil generic cost
Pingback: generic sildenafil tablets
Pingback: where can i buy viagra in usa
Pingback: lloyd pharmacy viagra
Pingback: cheap viagra usa
Pingback: online cialis reviews
Pingback: buying cialis without prescription
Pingback: order viagra online no prescription
Pingback: pharmacy prescription
Pingback: can you buy viagra in australia over the counter
Pingback: sildenafil for sale canada
Pingback: generic viagra online uk
Pingback: viagra 100 buy
Pingback: tadalafil 60 mg reviews
Pingback: cialis professional vs cialis super active
Pingback: tadalafil generic vs brand
Pingback: gabapentin packungsgrössen
Pingback: flagyl searle
Pingback: ic sulfamethoxazole tmp ds
Pingback: valtrex nosečnost
Pingback: lyrica withdrawal timeline
Pingback: lisinopril edema
Pingback: metformin accutane
Pingback: what does 3mg of rybelsus do
Pingback: rybelsus type 2 diabetes
Pingback: 911
Pingback: psy
Pingback: link
Pingback: list
Pingback: how does zoloft make you feel
Pingback: azithromycin how does it work
Pingback: metronidazole moisturizer
Pingback: a
Pingback: Tucker Carlson - Vladimir Putin - 2024-02-09 Putin interview summary, full interview.
Pingback: Tucker Carlson - Vladimir Putin
Pingback: keflex doses
Pingback: gabapentin dosing
Pingback: can i stop duloxetine suddenly
Pingback: escitalopram 20mg tablets
Pingback: batman apollo ru
Pingback: amoxicillin resistance
Pingback: spiraldynamics
Pingback: Spiral Dynamics
Pingback: can cephalexin be used for ear infection
Pingback: bactrim dosage pediatric
Pingback: does bactrim treat yeast infections
Pingback: vxi.su
Pingback: is depakote an antipsychotic
Pingback: flomax flow cytometry
Pingback: ddavp patient assistance
Pingback: bcs class of ezetimibe
Pingback: how to get citalopram out of your system faster
Pingback: cozaar 50 mg uses
Pingback: verapamil and diltiazem
Pingback: contrave generic dosing
Pingback: horrible effexor withdrawals
Pingback: diclofenac topical
Pingback: how long does amitriptyline stay in your system
Pingback: site
Pingback: spisok
Pingback: bupropion xl 150
Pingback: buspar withdrawal
Pingback: augmentin for sinus infection
Pingback: celecoxib and sulfa allergy
Pingback: baclofen price
Pingback: remeron benefits
Pingback: actos psiquicos
Pingback: does robaxin help with opiate withdrawals
Pingback: protonix and zantac
Pingback: can abilify cause weight gain
Pingback: 25 units of semaglutide
Pingback: repaglinide metabolism