Commencement Bay



[Main] [Introduction] [Methods] [Results and Discussion] [Data Repository]


Results & Discussion

CTD Results

On April 13, 2012 we sampled stations 1- 4, representing a transect from the Thea Foss to the Hylebos Waterway. On April 20, 2012 we sampled stations 8 - 5, representing the same transect. Two other transects were sampled on April 20, 2012: one from Point Defiance to Browns Point, another from the outer central bay into the waterways.

Temperature
(°C)
Sampled on 13 April 2012 Sampled on 20 April 2012
Sampled on 20 April 2012

Sampled on 20 April 2012


Salinity
(PSU)
Sampled on 13 April 2012 Sampled on 20 April 2012

Sampled on 20 April 2012
Sampled on 20 April 2012

Density
(sigma t)
Sampled on 13 April 2012 Sampled on 20 April 2012

Sampled on 20 April 2012
Sampled on 20 April 2012

Temperature, Salinity and Density

These data show the effect of a rain event and tidal action on the water in Commencement Bay. CTD results show a slight thermocline at approximately 3 meters from the Thea Foss Waterway to the Hylebos Waterway on both April 13th and 20th, 2012. However, great variation exists in salinity measures between the two sampling dates. On the 13th, we saw a halocline at approximately 3 meters. On the 20th, results show relatively low salinity in the top 5 meters of the water column; this may be evidence of elevated freshwater discharge presumably from the Puyallup River. Precipitation data confirm this as a total of 2.13 cm of rain fell on April 19th up until 1:00 PM on April 20th (precipitation data), while there was zero precipitation on or before the 13th. The freshwater layer extends slightly deeper towards the Thea Foss Waterway side of the Bay. Sampling on the 20th took place during the incoming tide (tide chart), which created an uneven salt wedge which resulted in the freshwater bulge towards the Thea Foss. Density results concur with salinity results as the less dense freshwater from the Puyallup River comprises a slightly deeper layer on the Thea Foss Waterway side of the Bay. While on the 13th, the pycnocline is slightly deeper on the Hylebos Waterway side.

On April 20th, CTD results for the transect extending from Point Defiance to Browns Point showed no discernible thermocline, indicating a well-mixed system. A slight halocline and pycnocline were evident at approximately 5 meters on the Browns Point side but not on the Point Defiance side.

For the transect extending from the Mid Channel in towards the waterways, results show a well-mixed system with no significant change throughout the water column. Expected results would show a more stratified water column nearer the waterways and less stratified towards the outer bay.

Dissolved Oxygen
(mg/L)
Dissolved Oxygen CTD vs Winkler Method: 13 April 2012

Dissolved Oxygen CTD vs Winkler Method: 20 April 2012

Sampled on 13 April 2012 Sampled on 20 April 2012

Sampled on 20 April 2012
Sampled on 20 April 2012

Dissolved Oxygen

CTD Dissolved Oxygen results show that water from the Thea Foss Waterway to the Hylebos Waterway on both sampling days was classified as "excellent" by the Washington State dissolved oxygen standards. Results were similar at the other transects.

Fluorescence
(mg/m3)
Chlorophyll/Fluorescence CTD vs. Strickland Parsons Method: 13 April 2012

Chlorophyll/Fluorescence CTD vs. Strickland Parsons Method: 20 April 2012

Sampled on 13 April 2012 Sampled on 20 April 2012

Sampled on 20 April 2012

Sampled on 20 April 2012


Fluorescence

The only discernible fluorescence results were from the 13th, where a layer extended from 3 to 13 meters on the Hylebos side, with higher concentrations in a shallower layer on the Thea Foss side.

Transmissivity
(%)
Sampled on 13 April 2012 Sampled on 20 April 2012

Sampled on 13 April 2012

Sampled on 20 April 2012

Transmissivity

CTD transmissivity results on the 20th compared to the 13th show an increase in suspended particles in the upper 4 meters of the water column along the transect extending from the Thea Foss Waterway to the Hylebos Waterway. On the outer bay transect, the upper 10 meters show a relatively higher concentration of suspended particles than the remaining water column. From the Mid channel to the waterways a layer of suspended particles extends deeper into the water column towards the waterways from the outer bay. There is also an increase in transmissivity at a depth of approximately 70 to 125 meters extending from the waterways towards the mid channel, this could be an indication of effluent discharge from the Central Tacoma Wastewater Treatment Facility.

Secchi

Secchi reading on the 13th were greatest at station 1 located near the mouth of the Thea Foss and lowest at station 3 located near the sewage outfall buoy. On the 20th, station 1 near Point Defiance was the highest while station 7 near the mouth of the Puyallup was the lowest. Comparison of two sample days show a decrease in secchi depth corresponding to increased river discharge caused by heavy precipication.

Phytoplankton

Phytoplankton Net Results

Phytoplankton Results

Phytoplankton genera was widely variable amongst all stations on April 13th. Detonula spp.was noticeably present at stations 3, 4 and 5. The outermost stations, 5 and 6, had the greatest genera diversity. Station 2, located at the mouth of the Puyallup River, had the lowest genera diversity.

Detonula spp., Chaetoceros spp. and Skeletonema spp.were found in greater concentrations on April 20th in both the thermocline and surface. There was greater overall genera diversity on the 20th compared to the 13th. Station 2 on the 20th had an increase in phytoplankton concentration and diversity compared to the 3th, presumably due to the increase in nutrients from the rain event. Station 2, sampled on the 20th, located in the outer bay had the lowest phytoplankton diversity.

Nutrients

Five nutrients were tested within QMH waters. Dissolved inorganic nitrogen (DIN) is most commonly found in marine waters in the forms of NH4, NO3, and NO2, of which all are primary sources of nitrogen for phytoplankton (Rensel 1991). PO4 is a primary source of phosphorous for phytoplankton and is essential in metabolic processes. Phosphorous may be limited in areas highly influenced by rivers due to the high concentrations of nitrogen carried in their waters (Rensel 1991). Si(OH)4 is incorporated into the cell walls of diatoms and is essential to their production (Rugdale et al. 2001). In periods of high phytoplankton production DIN, PO4 and Si(OH)4 are absorbed out of the system, in turn reducing concentrations.

Nutrient results from April 13th, 2012 show that Si(OH)4 was variable at the surface while consistent at the bottom. Station 6 had the highest concentration, while station 4 had the lowest. All stations had higher concentrations at the surface than the bottom. On the 20th of April, concentrations of Si(OH)4 were highest at the surface at station 7 and highest at the thermocline at station 5, while the bottom concentrations were insignificantly variable. All stations had higher Si(OH)4 concentrations at the surface than the thermocline, except at station 5 where the thermocline concentrations were much greater than the surface.

On April 13th, 2012, the ratio between phosphate and nitrate were lowest at station 3 with a ratio of 1: 11.20, and highest at station 6 with a ratio of 1: 11.88. The ratio between phosphate and nitrate on the 20th of April was lowest at station 1 with a ratio of 1: 11.24, and highest at station 7 with a ratio of 1: 19.91. Both stations had ratios of between 5-20, indicating a normal system, where neither phosphate nor nitrate was in short supply (Rensel et al. 1991). Dissolved inorganic nitrogen (DIN) and phosphate ratios were consistent in the bottom waters on both sampling days. On the 13th DIN to phosphate ratios in the surface were approximately 12, with the exception of station 6 were the ratio spiked to 19.34. The rise in the ratio may possibly be due to its location near a sewage outfall at Puget Creek or from the Puyallup River plume extending to that area. Phosphate to nitrate ratios showed similar trends, with station 6 having the highest ratio. On the 20th, the highest DIN to phosphate ratio is at station 7 with a value of 23.17. The elevated ratio may be due to the station location at the mouth of the Puyallup River. Phosphate to nitrate ratios were similar to DIN to phosphate ratios, with station 7 having the highest ratio.

Sediment and TOC

Sediment and TOC

On April 13th, sediment analysis results show that station 2 and 3 were similar in composition, presumably influenced heavily by sedimentation of the Puyallup River. Station 1 is located outside of the Thea Foss, and had relatively coarser particle composition. Relatedly, the %TOC was higher in station 2 and 3 where the finer sediments provide a larger surface to volume ratio for the adsorption of organics.

On the 20th, station 1, located near Point Defiance and station 5, located near the mouth of the Hylebos waterway showed similar grain size composition. However, the TOC content was much higher at station 5, this could be attributed to the close proximity to the sewage outfall.

Expected nutrient concentrations are low where phytoplankton abundance is high; however the results from these samples do not follow this trend. For example, station 3 contained 5 phytoplankton genera in bloom; however the DIN to Phosphate ratio and the Nitrate to Phosphate ratio were average in comparison to the other sampled stations. These results may be skewed as a result of a lack of phytoplankton identification experience.

References Rensel and Associates. 1991. Nutrients and phytoplankton in Puget Sound. Seattle (WA): EPA: 150p.

Rugdale RC, Wilkerson FP. 2001. Sources and fates of silicon in the ocean: the role of diatoms in the climate and glacial cycles. Scientia Marina 65(2):141-52

[Main] [Introduction] [Methods] [Results and Discussion] [Data Repository]

Created by Elisa Rauschl and Samantha Petrie